processing...
Brand Logo
TAVR vs Open Heart Surgery: Which Valve Replacement Is Right for You? TAVR vs Open Heart Surgery: Which Valve Replacement Is Right for You?

TAVR vs Open Heart Surgery: Which Valve Replacement Is Right for You?

October 22, 2026 |
TAVR vs Open Heart Surgery: Which Valve Replacement Is Right for You? 9 Min Read | 110

TAVR and open-heart surgery are procedures that help to replace a narrowed or blocked aortic valve with a new one. Both use a different approach and the eligibility varies from one person to another, depending on various factors.

TAVR, or transcatheter aortic valve replacement, is a minimally invasive procedure. This is done without making a large incision on the chest. The approach used is transcatheter, in which a small catheter is used to introduce the new valve into the blood vessels through a tiny incision in the groin or arm. 

Open heart surgery Is done using the conventional approach. Here, doctors access the affected valve by making an incision across the chest and removing the breastbone. 

If you have been diagnosed with severe aortic stenosis and your doctor has recommended valve replacement, the next question is usually: should you go for a TAVR procedure or traditional open-heart surgery?

The answer depends on many factors, age, surgical risk, valve shape and life expectancy. This blog will help you understand all about TAVR and open heart surgery, and which one would be the right option for you.

What Is Aortic Stenosis?

Aortic stenosis is a condition marked by stiffening or narrowing of the aortic valve. This is one of the four valves of the heart that serves as the door between the heart’s main pumping chamber, i.e. the left ventricle and the main artery, the aorta.  

Aortic stenosis can make it difficult for the heart to push out blood, which puts an extra strain on the heart muscles. As time passes by, this pressure can impair the left side of the heart.

Some cases can also be congenital, which means that the valve defect is present since birth.

The condition is commonly seen in elderly people as it results from age related calcification and scarring. A 2019 Review on the Current Status Of Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement In India, suggests that age-related calcific aortic stenosis has high mortality if not treated. The review further highlights the proven efficacy of aortic valve replacement (AVR) in reducing mortality of patients with aortic stenosis.

What Are The Symptoms Of Aortic Stenosis?

Symptoms of aortic stenosis develop gradually as the condition progresses. This happens when the valve becomes too narrow and affects the flow of blood. Common symptoms include:

  • Breathlessness on exertion
  • Chest pain or tightness
  • Dizziness or fainting
  • Unusual tiredness
  • Palpitations

According to NHS, Heart, while replacement can help to ease the symptoms of heart, while disease such as chest pain, dizziness, breathlessness, palpitations, and tiredness.  In severe cases, the procedure might even be recommended before the onset of symptoms. This is done when the risks of heart attack are high.

What Is The TAVR Procedure?

TAVR procedure, or transcatheter aortic valve replacement procedure, is performed with the same aim as the standard open heart surgery, to replace a dysfunctional aortic valve. However, the route taken to do so is entirely different.

Unlike the open-heart surgery in which doctors make a surgical incision across the chest, TAVR follow a minimally invasive approach. In this case, doctors make tiny keyhole punctures or incisions, most often in the groin, to introduce the new valve.

Precise imaging technique is used for live monitoring, while the valve is carefully moved towards the affected part of the heart. During the procedure, the heart is not stopped, and, as such, there is no need for a heart-lung bypass machine. The old valve is left intact while the new one is placed inside it.

What Are The Steps Involved In TAVR Procedure?

Various steps involved in a TAVR procedure are:

  • Assessment: The most important step is proper assessment. Your doctors may ask for a few tests and scans to see whether the procedure is right for you. They will also check the size and condition of your aorta and the blood vessels leading to it, so the treatment can be planned around your body.
  • Once your tests are done, your doctors will build a treatment plan around you and talk it through with you. They’ll explain the pros and cons of the procedure, how to prepare for it and what to expect, so nothing comes as a surprise.
  • Procedure: The TAVR procedure is performed in a cath lab using local anaesthesia and sedation. The surgical back up is kept on standby to ensure that, in case of any emergency, everything is in place and sorted.
  • Valve placement: The new valve is carefully positioned inside the damaged valve and expanded using a tiny balloon. This is done multiple times, until the normal flow of blood is restored.
  • Recovery: This is as crucial as any other step of the procedure and determines its success rate to a great extent. Doctors usually perform an echocardiogram to assess whether the valve is functioning properly or not.

What Is Open Heart Aortic Valve Replacement Surgery?

Open heart aortic valve replacement surgery, or SAVR, uses the conventional approach for valve replacement. It is performed under general anaesthesia and involves the opening of the breastbone to directly access the valve. During the procedure, the patient's heart is stopped temporarily, and hence a heart-lung bypass machine is used.

An open heart surgery may involve the use of two different types of valves. These are:

  • Mechanical valve: This is made of carbon and metal. Although it is long-lasting, the patient needs to take lifelong blood thinners
  • Biological (tissue): This is made from animal tissue, needing fewer blood thinners but wearing out over time

TAVR vs Open Heart Surgery

Feature TAVR Open heart surgery (SAVR)
Access Small puncture, usually in the groin Incision through the breastbone
Anaesthesia Often sedation General anaesthesia
Heart-lung machine Not required Required
Hospital stay Usually shorter Usually longer
Recovery Often quicker Takes weeks to months
Valve type Tissue valve Tissue or mechanical valve
Long-term durability data Still maturing Longest track record
Treats other heart problems at once Limited Yes, such as bypass or other valves
Typical concerns Pacemaker need, vessel injury, leak around the valve, stroke Bleeding, infection, rhythm problems, longer recovery

Who Is Suited To Which Option

When it comes to choosing the right surgery for the patient, doctors don't just go by their gut feeling. There is a proper protocol to be followed. According to the 2020 American College of Cardiology and American Heart Association guidelines:

  • Surgery is preferred for people under the age of 65 with a life expectancy of over 20 years
  • Either surgery or transfemoral TAVR is recommended for people lying in the age group of 65 to 80 years.
  • Transfemoral TAVR is preferred for people over eighty with a life expectancy of 10 years, when feasible.

Doctors may also take into account the following factors when planning the right surgery for you:

  • What is your age and expected life expectancy?
  • How risky is the surgery for you?
  • What is the condition of your valve?
  • Are your blood vessels suitable for TAVR?
  • Is there any other underlying condition that requires a surgical fix?
  • Is your condition rheumatic? (In such cases, surgery is usually recommended).
  • What is the goal of your surgery?

Conclusion

Both TAVR and open-heart surgery are well-established methods of replacing a narrowed aortic valve. The one that would be right for you depends on many factors, including your age, risk factors, goals, etc. Consult a trusted cardiologist at Artemis Hospital to review your reports and discuss which surgical procedure suits you better

FAQs

1. What is the TAVR procedure?

TAVR stands for Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement. It is a minimally invasive procedure to remove a damaged valve and replace it with a new one.

2. Is TAVR better than open-heart surgery?

TAVR can be a better option than open-heart surgery for some patients. However, for others, the latter is a better fit. The best way to find out is by consulting an expert and getting yourself evaluated

3. Who is eligible for TAVR?

TAVR is recommended for patients with severe aortic stenosis who have suitable blood vessels. Other factors that can impact your eligibility include age and overall health.

4. How long does recovery take after TAVR?

Recovery from TAVR is usually quicker compared to open-heart surgery. Hospital stay can last for about 2 to 3 days, following which you might need some rest and care at home.

5. How long does a TAVR valve last?

The TAVR procedure involves the use of tissue valves, which can last for around 15 to 20 years.

References

  • NHS. Heart valve replacement: how it's done
  • NHS. Recovering from a heart valve replacement
  • NHS. Why a heart valve replacement is done
  • American College of Cardiology. 2020 ACC/AHA valvular heart disease guideline: key points
  • Mack MJ, et al. Transcatheter aortic-valve replacement with a balloon-expandable valve in low-risk patients (PARTNER 3). New England Journal of Medicine. 2019. DOI
  • TCTMD. Low-risk trials cement a role for TAVR alongside, or in place of, surgery (PARTNER 3 and Evolut Low Risk)
  • Manjunath CN, et al. Incidence and patterns of valvular heart disease in a tertiary care high-volume cardiac center. Indian Heart Journal. 2014;66(3):320-326. Full text
  • Transcatheter aortic valve replacement in India: early experience, challenges, and outcomes from a single center. Indian Heart Journal. 2018. Full text
  • TAVR in intermediate and high-risk patients at two armed forces cardiac centres. Medical Journal Armed Forces India. Summary

Medical Disclaimer

This article is for educational purposes only. It is not medical advice and does not replace diagnosis or treatment by a qualified cardiologist or cardiac surgeon. Treatment choice depends on individual assessment by a heart team, and no outcome can be guaranteed. Please consult a registered medical practitioner about any heart symptoms, and seek emergency care for severe chest pain or breathlessness.

Enquire Now

Want to connect with our team for a hassle-free experience? Share your details and we will get in touch at the earliest.

Latest Blogs

From Recent Advancements in Heart Care to Tips and Tricks to make your Heart Healthy Again, stay updated with reliable and informative blogs by our experts.

Our Locations

Artemis Cardiac Center